{ "all_original_failures_preserved": [ { "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-02-A", "explanation": "A real provider proposal was received, but the original operation published no usable semantic decision after mechanical grounding. This remains a technical halt, with no semantic-refusal credit.", "kind": "technical_failure" }, { "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-02-B", "explanation": "The actual question is concrete and its main diagnosis is grounded, but its complete delivered unit contains an unsupported visible-fact premise. Preserved in both initial and final output; detailed gold comparison stays private.", "kind": "unsupported_confident_delivered_review_claim" } ], "artifact_validation": { "accepted_exports": 7, "accepted_exports_equal_frozen_pure_pose_construction": 7, "accepted_exports_mandatory215_interpretation_gates_passed": 7, "accepted_exports_original_eight_guards_passed": 7, "accepted_packages_crc_members_and_exact_external_bytes_verified": 7, "baseline_exports_render_validated": 6, "baseline_source_pose_comparisons_passed": 36, "correct_initial_ready_export_coverage": "7/7 total; adaptive4/4, single-pass3/3", "declared_files_verified": 108, "manifest_frame_hashes_verified": 1668, "native_visual_export_qc_passed": 7, "provider_request_bodies_independently_reaudited": false, "shared_initial_receipt_parity": "6/6 pairs; CV facts, native frame hashes/times/dimensions, contact sheet and layer atlas" }, "assessed_at_utc": "2026-10-26T20:09:13.135288+00:00", "blinding_and_authorship": { "AI_authored_sources_and_reference": true, "AI_operator_proxy": true, "all_24_anonymous_ratings_sealed_before_join": true, "custodian_recovery_limit": "This resumed AI custodian read the existing frozen author reference. Previous custodian conversation history was not recovered; no stronger historical blinding claim is made. Before rating seal, parent disclosed aggregate result existence and seven approvals, not per-arm quality/cost results.", "delivered_content_may_reveal_method": true, "frozen_source_author_knowledge_retained": true, "full_or_double_blind_human_study": false, "limited_metadata_concealment_only": true, "raw_arm_records_viewed_by_resumed_annotator_before_seal": false }, "cost_scope": "Model request charges only. Historical model history is separate; infrastructure and artist time were not measured. Operator phase added zero model requests. Nested initial accounting is not double-counted.", "costs_by_arm": { "adaptive": { "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial_machine_seconds": 585.1052554230118, "operator_phase_physical_requests": 0, "physical_requests": 12, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 411234, "tool_actions": { "coverage_review_pending": 4, "events_measured": 4, "initial_contact_sheet": 6, "initial_layer_atlas": 6, "needs_review": 2, "observe": 2, "physical_candidates": 6, "propose_events": 4, "review_proposal": 4 } }, "single_pass_candidate_cv": { "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial_machine_seconds": 498.8416153709986, "operator_phase_physical_requests": 0, "physical_requests": 6, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 164320, "tool_actions": { "events_measured": 3, "initial_contact_sheet": 6, "initial_layer_atlas": 6, "needs_review": 2, "physical_candidates": 6, "propose_events": 4 } } }, "fixed_policy_secondary_candidates": { "last_frame": { "author_approved_exports": 0, "case_denominator": 6, "complete_visible_information_and_scope_candidates": 2, "product_accepted_exports": 0, "quality_comparable_to_approved_model_product": false, "review_required_cases_without_semantic_review": 2, "semantic_decisions": 0, "supported_ready_reference_cases": 4 }, "uniform_three": { "author_approved_exports": 0, "case_denominator": 6, "complete_visible_information_and_scope_candidates": 2, "product_accepted_exports": 0, "quality_comparable_to_approved_model_product": false, "review_required_cases_without_semantic_review": 2, "semantic_decisions": 0, "supported_ready_reference_cases": 4 } }, "frozen_source_commit": "0d7634a4a8eff5ecfa4fc80467571f97b72a0627", "historical_ledger_snapshot": { "all_history_included_not_trial_increment": true, "held_micro_usd": 402752, "held_reserve_not_released": true, "historical_unknown_cost_not_replaced_by_zero": true, "policy_cap_micro_usd": 2900000, "request_count": 68, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 1542714, "snapshot_kind": "Existing root read-only receipt; no new cloud or ledger access by custodian." }, "new_model_AWS_or_renderer_calls_for_this_assessment": 0, "no_claims": [ "Human comprehension", "Human artist time", "Medical comfort", "Population reliability", "Jury score", "Causal isolation of CV/reviewer", "Cost efficiency", "Randomized improvement from213to215" ], "preregistered_summary": { "adaptive_product_go": true, "arm_statistics": { "adaptive": { "all_accepted_export_guards_pass": true, "correct_ready_initial_count": 4, "correct_ready_initial_export_coverage_complete": true, "denominator": 6, "final_factual_correct": 6, "final_unsupported_confident_claims": 0, "initial_factual_correct": 6, "initial_semantically_executed": 6, "initial_unsupported_confident_claims": 0, "operator_action_count": 10, "protocol_integrity_verified": true }, "single_pass_candidate_cv": { "all_accepted_export_guards_pass": true, "correct_ready_initial_count": 3, "correct_ready_initial_export_coverage_complete": true, "denominator": 6, "final_factual_correct": 4, "final_unsupported_confident_claims": 1, "initial_factual_correct": 4, "initial_semantically_executed": 5, "initial_unsupported_confident_claims": 1, "operator_action_count": 9, "protocol_integrity_verified": true } }, "cost_efficiency_proven": false, "extra_adaptive_operator_actions": 1, "human_artist_time_measured": false, "human_comprehension_measured": false, "material_agent_advantage_criterion_met": false, "paired_adaptive_gains": 2, "paired_adaptive_losses": 0, "pairs": [ { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": false, "case_id": "E215-01-A", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true }, { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": false, "case_id": "E215-01-B", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true }, { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": true, "case_id": "E215-02-A", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true }, { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": true, "case_id": "E215-02-B", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true }, { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": false, "case_id": "E215-03-A", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true }, { "adaptive_loss": false, "adaptive_win": false, "case_id": "E215-03-B", "same_shared_initial_evidence": true } ], "schema": "calm215-paired-quality-summary-1", "timestamp_windows_used_for_semantic_score": false }, "private_assessment_commitment_sha256": "95ffb20a3738f43a111d511623c184a353cf27d4541dd0d9d20b53bad1442dff", "private_reference_detailed_annotations_or_mapping_published": false, "renderer_scope": { "all_unique_full_composition_images_inspected_and_repeated_frames_hash_verified": true, "registered_source_preparation_and_cheap_baselines": "lottie-web5.13.0; native Chromium156.0.4314.42 Canvas2D CPU", "same_player_sha256": "0930bfecb5b5dad59dd9049a139fa957e57f70e0805fc94a311204e524e45e28", "trial_and_assessment_image": "sha256:d78060f950043fac2e4dba44577f8e47f7a918d0c6078bbcabee72676870d913", "trial_and_postseal_review": "lottie-web5.13.0; native Chromium151.0.7922.34 Canvas2D CPU" }, "review_actionability": { "actual_concrete_author_questions": 4, "actual_delivered_questions_audited": 4, "fully_correct_review_outcomes": 3, "grounded_diagnosis_without_question_full_credit": 0, "grounded_specific_diagnoses": 4, "note": "Counts are initial decisions; identical persisted final units are retained and audited, not counted as new independent evidence." }, "rows": [ { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-01-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 131.40078363000066, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 79992 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-01-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 112.28275030400255, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 29692 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-01-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 82.40161047400034, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 27526 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-01-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 105.13248146300612, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 67520 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-02-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 109.74908986399532, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 76044 }, { "actual_operator_approval": false, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-02-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": false, "checks_present": 0, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "technical_failure", "factual_outcome_correct": false, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": false, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "technical_failure", "factual_outcome_correct": false, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": false, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 95.71863499499159, "operator_action_count": 1, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 28370 }, { "actual_operator_approval": false, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-02-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": false, "checks_present": 0, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": false, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 1 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": false, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 1 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 70.91517897800077, "operator_action_count": 1, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 27866 }, { "actual_operator_approval": false, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-02-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": false, "checks_present": 0, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 79.10484728800657, "operator_action_count": 1, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 63786 }, { "actual_operator_approval": false, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-03-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": false, "checks_present": 0, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 79.45434750200366, "operator_action_count": 1, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 59902 }, { "actual_operator_approval": false, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-03-A", "export_guard": { "accepted": false, "checks_present": 0, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "needs_review", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": null, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": true, "review_concrete_author_question": true, "review_grounded_diagnosis": true, "review_specific_and_grounded": true, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 62.88632629600761, "operator_action_count": 1, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 25216 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "single_pass_candidate_cv", "case_id": "E215-03-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 74.63711432399577, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 1, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 25650 }, { "actual_operator_approval": true, "arm": "adaptive", "case_id": "E215-03-B", "export_guard": { "accepted": true, "checks_present": 8, "passed": true }, "final": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0, "initial": { "delivered_disposition": "ready", "factual_outcome_correct": true, "minimality_satisfied": true, "over_refusal": false, "review_complete_actionable": null, "review_concrete_author_question": null, "review_grounded_diagnosis": null, "review_specific_and_grounded": null, "semantically_executed": true, "uncertain_claims": 0, "unsupported_confident_claims": 0 }, "initial_machine_seconds": 80.26370567599952, "operator_action_count": 2, "physical_model_requests": 2, "settled_actual_micro_usd": 63990 } ], "runtime_custody": { "all44_runtime_files_verified_before_main_release": true, "frozen_runtime_archive": { "bytes": 642754, "path": "outputs/PulsePatch-3/evidence/FROZEN-RUNTIME-215.zip", "sha256": "45788e696921348faa9f6c43995065ae6fd40915e3e03cfcea1e4b56b158ed56" }, "later216_main_changes_do_not_change_closed215": true }, "schema": "calm215-public-factual-summary-1", "scope": "Agreement with a frozen AI-authored synthetic factual/relational reference and visible compositions; this is not an overall product rating or a human study.", "signature": { "meaning": "AI factual assessment authorship attestation, bound by SHA256 seals; not a human or cryptographic identity signature.", "signed_at_utc": "2026-10-26T20:09:13.136854+00:00", "signed_by": "AI custodian /root/custodian215" }, "signed_by": "AI custodian /root/custodian215", "total_trial_physical_requests": 18, "total_trial_settled_actual_micro_usd": 575554, "trial_held_or_unknown_micro_usd": 0 }